Penni Cyr thinks a bill recently introduced in the Idaho Legislature could drive teachers from Idaho.
"Everybody talks about wanting to attract the best and the brightest to the state of Idaho," said the Moscow High School librarian and National Education Association director for Idaho. "If this law is passed they will not attract anybody to the state of Idaho.
"They're just writing off any new teachers, anybody coming to our state to teach."
The Idaho Legislature voted Thursday to print a bill that theoretically would save the state $14.054 million next year by eliminating the public school teachers' early retirement program, freezing salaries and allowing districts to reduce salaries or contract days of experienced teachers.
Idaho State Rep. Bob Nonini, R-Coeur D'Alene, introduced the bill Thursday morning, with a stated purpose of reducing the cost of the fiscal year 2010 (July 2009-June 2010) public schools appropriation and giving schools flexibility in dealing with state budget cuts.
Cyr and other local educators are not thrilled about the prospects.
"I have extreme concerns, and I know every teacher in the state does," Cyr said.
Cyr said she feels lawmakers are rushing through the legislation and are poised to cripple education in Idaho.
"They need to wait and see what happens at the federal level," she said. "Let that economic stimulus package come to Idaho and help us."
Cyr and others are concerned that eliminating the early retirement program will reduce attrition and make it harder for younger, more affordable teachers to get jobs in Idaho.
Moscow School District Superintendent Candis Donicht was particularly surprised by the bill's proposal to move teacher contract deadlines from May 25 to July 1.
"There are things that I'm reading that are problematic, in that they could drive teachers to better-paying states where they have a contract in their hand," she said.
Educators also are concerned about the proposal to change Idaho law to allow districts to reduce salaries.
"That is an educator's protection ... that they are paid the same from year to year; they can't be paid less than they were last year," Cyr said, adding that it's been statutory law for more than 39 years.
Genesee School District Superintendent David Neumann said some administrators and school boards may prefer to keep their full staff at lower salaries to eliminating positions, but he's not among them.
"It's kind of against my personal philosophy," he said. "People have bills. ... To ask them to take a cut in pay or to balance the books on the back of staff is not necessarily the best situation."
Donicht said Idaho already is ranked behind most other states for teacher pay.
"If teachers' contract provisions and code language also become considered to be the least favorable of the states, yes we could lose teachers for better pay and job security," she said.
Nonini also introduced a bill Thursday intended to reduce cost and increase efficiency in student transportation. If passed, it will reduce state transportation reimbursements to 50 percent from 85 percent.