The immigration bill passed by the Senate last week (supported by Sen. Craig, opposed by Sen. Crapo), is a spectacularly bad piece of legislation, and appears to show an utter tone deafness on the part of the president and Senate Republicans to the prevailing sentiment of the American people.
Not only does the bill grant amnesty and a guaranteed path to citizenship for law breakers, it actually awards rights and privileges to illegals that U.S. citizens do not enjoy. According to Sen. Jeff Sessions of Alabama and Sen. Charles Grassley of Iowa, here are just some of the problems with the bill.
Illegal aliens must pay their back taxes, which sounds reasonable until you discover that they only have to pay back taxes for three of the last five years, and get a complete pass on the other two. If an American citizen were to do the same - pick any two of the last five years and refuse to pay taxes for those years - that citizen would wind up in jail. As Sen. Grassley said, "The bill would treat lawbreakers better than the American people."
Also, the federal government will fine illegals only $2,000, which they would not be required to pay until the end of the adjudication process, which could take as long as 8 years.
Further, the federal government is not allowed to use the information
provided on an amnesty application for any purpose other than adjudicating the petition, even if the applicant confesses he is related to Osama Bin Laden. Our Senate has passed a bill that would outlaw the use of information supplied by illegal aliens for national security purposes.
If a federal agent does in fact use application information for some other purpose, such as national security, he is subject, not to a $2,000 fine, but to a $10,000 fine. In other words, law enforcement officers in the United States have greater legal exposure under this bill than illegal aliens.
Employers of illegals receive a blanket pardon for any tax cheating they have done by not paying withholding taxes, thus receiving amnesty themselves for something that would send an employer of American citizens to jail.
Robert Rector of the Heritage Foundation concludes that the bill, due to
generous provisions for immediate and extended family members, will virtually guarantee U.S. admission to an additional 60 million (yes, 60 million) immigrants.
According to Rector, this bill represents the largest expansion of welfare in the last 35 years, and would be a financial catastrophe. Illegals will be eligible for the earned income credit, which will wind up costing ordinary taxpayers $29 billion over the next ten years. Other social costs will burden taxpayers to the tune of $50 to $60 billion dollars every year for at least the next decade.
Illegals will not be required to submit to screening for communicable diseases. This will only exacerbate the resurgence we are seeing in tuberculosis, leprosy, dengue fever and other exotic diseases which had been virtually eliminated from the American populace.
Under this bill, aliens can only be fired for "just cause", and thus will have greater protection for employment than most American citizens, who are "at will" employees and can be fired for any number of reasons.
To make matters worse, the bill guarantees illegals access to a taxpayer funded arbitration process, which includes a taxpayer-funded lawyer, for any alien who feels he was let go for something other than "just cause."
And finally, the bill allows states to charge in-state tuition to amnestees, a privilege denied to ordinary, out of state Americans.
The good news is that leaders in the House seem determined not to capitulate on these matters, and are intent on securing our borders as a first, and if necessary, independent step.
HUMAN EVENTS ONLINE - Immigration Bill Is Worse Than You Think
Idaho Values Alliance: Illegal Immigration: Can America Afford the Cost?